Skip to Main Content

PSYC 101 - General Psychology - Bailey (Harrisburg)

Peer- Reviewed Articles: What are they?

The phrase peer-reviewed is used interchangeably with professional, scholarly, and academic, but they all refer to the same thing: an article that has undergone a specific publishing process called "peer-review". These articles are typically held to high standards for their quality of research and overall contribution to the knowledge of the topic being researched. Because of that, it can be difficult to read and understand these articles because of their audience and purpose. 

This page includes information to help you understand why peer-reviewed articles are such a big deal, ways to identify that something is likely peer-reviewed, and how to read and understand a scholarly article. 

FYI: You can find scholarly journals in any of our library databases. For this assignment, however, your best bet is PsycInfo. Many of the things you learn about PsycInfo are applicable to all databases.

Peer-Reviewed Articles: How they get published

1. Conduct Original Research

Original research is done when the researchers are responsible for the entire process of coming up with a hypothesis, a means for testing the hypothesis, defending their hypothesis based on prior research, and gathering and analyzing the data, and explaining their findings. This is often done by scientists, doctors, college professors, or people working within a field of study.

2. Write

Researchers must present their findings in a very thorough manner so that other researchers could replicate their work and reach the same conclusions. Their writing must follow specific style rules and writing conventions that match the preference of the publication, or journal, where they will submit their work.

Peer-Reviewed Articles: How to recognize them

Title

The title is typically very clear about the article's content and uses accurate and professional language.

Peer-Reviewed Articles: How to Read them

1. Read the abstract. 

Remember that it is a summary, and this is going to give you an idea of what you can look for when you go through the article itself. 

2. Read what you understand, and skim what you don't. 

Most research articles have the same clearly outlined sections: Introduction, Literature Review, Methodology, Results, Discussion, and Conclusion. While they may be called different things, the results section is going to be the least accessible and is explained in the discussion. The literature review can be a visual distraction with all the references, but you will eventually mentally ignore the references as you read more scholarly literature.

3. Keep your own research in mind.

It is easy to forget what you are researching and get pulled in multiple directions. Make sure you are reading it from the perspective of how this informs your own research rather than focusing on their research.

Anatomy of a Scholarly Article

decorative

Anatomy of a Scholarly Article

This interactive image explains common elements of a scholarly article, including the abstract, introduction and conclusion.